First Who ... Then What · SOURCE-CHECKED ANALYSIS

The same image distinguishes reassignment from removal

The same image identifies a sequence of actions and is reused to clarify a later decision boundary.

Good to Great cover

Good to Great

Jim Collins · 41 weeks

The same image distinguishes reassignment from removal

WHAT HAPPENS IN THE BOOK

Later in the chapter, Collins uses Gillette and Circuit City accounts to distinguish a capable person in a poorly matched role from a person who should leave. The bus’s seats let him amend an interpretation that would otherwise collapse every personnel problem into removal.

THE AUTHOR’S DECISION

A useful metaphor can become more precise on its return: the later passage adds a decision the first telling left compressed.

The source in context.

The bus metaphor puts personnel choices ahead of choosing a direction. Company cases lead into practical hiring and assignment distinctions, including the difference between the wrong person and the wrong role.

Open this chapter

What this example supports

A useful metaphor can become more precise on its return: the later passage adds a decision the first telling left compressed.

Its limit

The passage is a reported management interpretation, with no independent assessment here of the underlying decisions or their effects.

Source & edition

Jim Collins, Good to Great; inspected local source text, local electronic-text extraction with a 2001 copyright notice; print pagination and graphical layout not verified.

Supplied text, lines 1961–1988. The description is an original editorial paraphrase, not a quotation.

Codex editorial pass used the existing whole-source AI draft as a set of nominations, checked the original local source at every quoted example and its surrounding passages, checked chapter headings and section order, and rewrote or narrowed the selected interpretations. Chapter maps combine that draft with direct checks of headings, openings, and selected passages; this pass is not a new page-by-page reading or an independent-model review.

local electronic-text extraction with a 2001 copyright notice; print pagination and graphical layout not verified